The namesake well is a historic freshwater well that was used by pirates and early settlers. It is a notable landmark in the area and offers insight into the island's past and survival methods.

The island boasts several beautiful, unspoiled beaches perfect for swimming, sunbathing, and beachcombing. The clear waters are ideal for snorkeling and observing marine life.

The coral reefs surrounding Mayaguana are vibrant and diverse, making them a popular spot for snorkeling and diving enthusiasts. The reefs support a variety of marine species and contribute to the island's natural beauty.

Fishing is a traditional activity in Pirates Well, and visitors can experience local fishing culture or join fishing excursions to catch species like snapper and grouper.

Scattered around the island are several historical sites that tell the story of Mayaguana's settlement and development, including remnants of old buildings and artifacts.

Nature trails on Mayaguana offer visitors a chance to explore the island's flora and fauna, with opportunities for bird watching and enjoying the peaceful natural surroundings.

Visitors can enjoy authentic Bahamian dishes at local eateries, featuring fresh seafood and traditional recipes that reflect the island's cultural heritage.

Occasional cultural events and festivals in Pirates Well showcase Bahamian music, dance, and crafts, providing an immersive cultural experience for visitors.

Boat tours around Mayaguana offer scenic views of the coastline, opportunities to visit nearby cays, and chances to spot marine wildlife such as dolphins and sea turtles.

Due to its remote location and low light pollution, Pirates Well is an excellent spot for stargazing, offering clear night skies and spectacular views of constellations and celestial events.